Engine disagreement

When ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and Gemini name a business for the same question, how often they name the same one, per trade, with the questions compared and the questions left out.

Across the trades

Across 2 of 3 trades, each trade's newest week, Oct 12, 2026 to Nov 22, 2026: every engine that named a business named the same business most on 5 of 13 questions compared, and no two engines that named a business agreed on 0. 13 questions are too few to state as a percentage (we state one from 20), so this is not a finding yet.

Engines compared: ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and Gemini.

Across 2 of 3 trades, each trade's newest week, Oct 12, 2026 to Nov 22, 2026, not counted: 18 questions where fewer than two engines named a business.

Across 2 of 3 trades, each trade's newest week, Oct 12, 2026 to Nov 22, 2026: each pair of engines, over the questions where both named a business. A share is stated only from 20 questions up; below that, the counts are the finding.

EnginesQuestions where both named a businessSame business named mostShare
ChatGPT and Claude117too few to rate
ChatGPT and Perplexity62too few to rate
ChatGPT and Gemini127too few to rate
Claude and Perplexity55too few to rate
Claude and Gemini129too few to rate
Perplexity and Gemini62too few to rate

Windows and doors in Phoenix

In the week of Nov 16, 2026: every engine that named a business named the same business most on 4 of 7 questions compared, and no two engines that named a business agreed on 0. 7 questions are too few to state as a percentage (we state one from 20), so this is not a finding yet.

Engines compared: ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini. Perplexity took part in no comparison (no answers, or no business named).

Not counted: 10 questions where fewer than two engines named a business.

Which engines named a business, per question compared

Engines that named a businessQuestionsAll of them agreedNo two agreed
ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini630
Claude, Gemini110

Each pair of engines

EnginesQuestions where both named a businessSame business named mostShare
ChatGPT and Claude64too few to rate
ChatGPT and Gemini64too few to rate
Claude and Gemini76too few to rate

Download: CSV · JSON · dataset page. CC BY 4.0.

Roofing in Phoenix

In the week of Oct 12, 2026: every engine that named a business named the same business most on 1 of 6 questions compared, and no two engines that named a business agreed on 0. 6 questions are too few to state as a percentage (we state one from 20), so this is not a finding yet.

Engines compared: ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and Gemini.

Not counted: 8 questions where fewer than two engines named a business.

Which engines named a business, per question compared

Engines that named a businessQuestionsAll of them agreedNo two agreed
ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini510
ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini100

Each pair of engines

EnginesQuestions where both named a businessSame business named mostShare
ChatGPT and Claude53too few to rate
ChatGPT and Perplexity62too few to rate
ChatGPT and Gemini63too few to rate
Claude and Perplexity55too few to rate
Claude and Gemini53too few to rate
Perplexity and Gemini62too few to rate

Download: CSV · JSON · dataset page. CC BY 4.0.

How this is measured

For each question a homeowner asks in the trade's newest weekly run, we take each engine's most-named businesses (the ones named in the most of that engine's answers to the question, ties included) and compare them across engines. Only the engines that named a business on a question take part in it: an engine that answered but named nobody is left out of that question. A question is compared when at least two engines named a business; the questions where fewer than two did are counted apart and not compared. Every engine that named a business agrees when all of their most-named sets share a business; no two agree when no pair of them shares one; a pair overlaps when its two sets share a business, counted over the questions where both named a business. The questions are not published. Results describe what was measured, not a promise of ranking.

See what the engines say about your business.

A free audit by our AI business engine: it crawls your site the way AI crawlers do and emails you a score out of 100 and the three findings that matter most.